Bryoria fremontii - Edible Horsehair Lichen (Wila)

Family: Parmeliaceae [1]

Google Gemini - Created with AI prompt (This page needs scrutiny)

Bryoria fremontii - Flickr - pellaea (1)
Bryoria fremontii
(Wikimedia)1
WilaBig
Bryoria fremontii
(Wikimedia)2
Loaf of cooked wila lichen
Bryoria fremontii
(Wikimedia)3

1. Introduction to Bryoria fremontii

Bryoria fremontii is a distinctive dark brown, horsehair lichen, classified within the genus Bryoria and belonging to the Parmeliaceae family.[1] This genus encompasses approximately 23 other species in North America, many of which share similar appearances, making precise identification challenging.[1]

1.1. Classification and Nomenclature

Historically, Bryoria fremontii was sometimes referred to by the synonym Alectoria jubata.[5] More recent advancements in taxonomic research, particularly through the application of molecular data and DNA comparisons, have significantly refined its classification. These studies have conclusively demonstrated that Bryoria tortuosa, previously considered a separate species, is in fact conspecific with Bryoria fremontii.[2] This means they are now recognized as the same species, with observed variations between them attributed to differences influenced by their respective North American and European habitats.[2] Consequently, B. tortuosa has been formally synonymized with B. fremontii.[2]

1.2. Morphological Characteristics

Bryoria fremontii exhibits several key morphological features. Its main branches are notably thick, typically exceeding 0.4 mm in width, and often become flattened, twisted, and wrinkled in older specimens.[1] In contrast, most other Bryoria species possess narrower main branches.[1] B. fremontii is also unique in its remarkable length, regularly growing longer than 20 cm and occasionally reaching up to 90 cm.[1]

While generally dark brown, the lichen's color can vary, with some specimens exhibiting yellowish-brown or even bright yellow hues due to the presence of vulpinic acid.[1] Soredia (asexual reproductive structures) and apothecia (sexual reproductive structures) are uncommon. However, when present, they are highly distinctive due to their bright yellow coloration.[1] For practical identification, particularly concerning edibility, a more reliable characteristic for distinguishing poisonous specimens is the presence of abundant, long, yellow pseudocyphellae that twist around the main branches, visible with a hand lens.[1]

1.3. Habitat and Ecological Significance

Bryoria fremontii is an arboreal hair lichen, typically found hanging pendulously from trees, predominantly conifers, across western North America, northern Europe, and Asia.[1] It thrives in mountainous areas, commonly found at elevations between 1,200 and 2,300 meters in North America, though occasionally as low as 700 meters.[1] The lichen demonstrates a preference for drier forests with more open canopies. Within a forest, it is most abundant on trees and parts of trees that are less shaded, including dead or dying trees and older, defoliated branches.[1] Its abundance significantly increases with stand openness.[7]

Ecologically, B. fremontii holds substantial importance. It contains protein (2.5–5% dry weight) and lichenin (15–35% dry weight), a digestible carbohydrate for certain animals.[1] It serves as a vital food source for various ungulates and rodents, most notably the northern flying squirrel (Glaucomys sabrinus) and the woodland caribou (Rangifer tarandus caribou), particularly during winter.[1] The northern flying squirrel also uses this lichen for nest construction.[1] Hair lichens like Bryoria contribute to nutrient and water cycling and are indicators of forest ecosystem integrity.[8]

2. Geographic Distribution and Conservation Status

2.1. Global and Regional Distribution

Bryoria fremontii is widely distributed across western North America (Canada, USA, Mexico), northern Europe (Norway, Sweden, Finland, Russia), and Asia.[1][6] It has an estimated range exceeding 2,500,000 square kilometers with over 300 estimated occurrences globally.[6] Disjunct populations are recorded in Ontario, Manitoba, and Colorado.[6]

2.2. Environmental Conditions and Limiting Factors

Bryoria fremontii is an epiphyte on conifers and deciduous trees in open or shady forests.[6] It prefers drier forests with open canopies and less shaded conditions.[1][7] It benefits from rapid drying after rain and is intolerant of prolonged wetting.[7] Dark pigments (melanins) protect its algae from excess light and facilitate snowmelt for winter water and photosynthesis.[8]

2.3. Conservation Status and Threats

Globally, Bryoria fremontii is classified as "Least Concern" (LC) by the IUCN Red List.[5] NatureServe considers it "secure" globally.[6]

Potential threats include air pollution, logging, climate change, urban development, high-intensity wildfires, and fire suppression practices.[6] Regionally, it is presumed extirpated from the Sonoran Desert region since 1904.[6] Declines in related hair lichens in Fennoscandia are linked to pollution and forestry.[8]

3. Traditional Uses and Ethnobotanical Significance

Bryoria fremontii holds profound ethnobotanical significance, particularly among Indigenous peoples of North America.

3.1. Use as a Traditional Food Source

Known as "wila," Bryoria fremontii has been an important traditional food for several First Nations, including the Secwepemc, Shuswap, Nlaka'pamux, Lillooet, and Sinkaietk peoples.[1] It was traditionally pit-cooked with carbohydrate-rich foods (e.g., camas bulbs, saskatoonberries), allowing the lichen to absorb sugars and increase its carbohydrate content by 23% to 122%.[10] Harvesting involved twisting the lichen around a long stick ("txipmn" in Okanagan).[1] Cleaning ("kálka" in Secwepemc) involved hand-cleaning, soaking (often in running water), and sometimes pounding to remove debris and water-soluble toxic vulpinic acid.[1] Careful selection was crucial, as yellowish specimens or those with abundant yellow pseudocyphellae were considered poisonous.[1]

3.2. Traditional Medicinal Applications

Spanish New Mexicans used it for pyorrhea (rubbed on gums) and powdered it for sores/injuries.[11] Generally, lichens are used in traditional medicine for wounds, skin disorders, respiratory and digestive problems, and gynecological concerns, leveraging their secondary metabolites and carbohydrates.[12]

3.3. Other Cultural and Practical Uses

B. fremontii was used as a source of dye and fiber. The Lillooet used it with Alectoria sarmentosa for clothing (ponchos, footwear), sometimes interwoven with stronger fibers.[11] Its absorbent qualities were valued for wound dressings, diapers, sanitary napkins, and wiping salmon.[11] Interior Salish peoples used it mixed with mud for chinking log cabins.[11] In Okanagan tradition, it is believed to have originated from Coyote's hair braid.[11]

Table 1: Summary of Traditional Uses of Bryoria fremontii by Indigenous Groups

Indigenous Group(s) Type of Use Specific Application/Method Key Details/Preparation Source ID(s)
Secwepemc, Shuswap, Nlaka'pamux, Lillooet, Sinkaietk, Flathead Food Pit-cooked with carbohydrate-rich foods (e.g., camas bulbs, saskatoonberries) Absorbs sugars, increasing carbohydrate content; cleaning (kálka) by soaking removes water-soluble vulpinic acid. [1], [10]
Spanish New Mexicans Medicine Rubbed on gums for pyorrhea; powdered and applied to sores/injuries Topical application for various ailments. [11]
Lillooet (Interior Salish), Thompson, other Interior Salish Clothing/Fiber Woven into ponchos and footwear (with Alectoria sarmentosa); interwoven with silverberry bark. Not high quality, used by poorer people; absorbent but impractical when wet. [11]
Various Indigenous Groups Material Wound dressings, baby diapers, sanitary napkins, wiping salmon. Valued for absorbent qualities. [11]
Interior Salish Peoples Building Material Mixed with mud for chinking log cabins. Utilized for structural integrity. [11]
Okanagan Cultural/Mythological Believed to originate from Coyote's hair braid. Deep cultural and spiritual significance. [11]

4. Phytochemistry and Pharmacology

4.1. Chemical Composition: Primary and Secondary Metabolites

Primary metabolites include protein (2.5–5% dry weight) and lichenin (15–35% dry weight).[1]

4.1.1. Vulpinic Acid: Presence, Toxicity, and Taxonomic Implications

Bryoria fremontii (and its conspecific B. tortuosa) are the only known Bryoria species to contain vulpinic acid, a toxic, bright yellow pulvinic acid derivative.[1][2] In some specimens, it's restricted to soralia and apothecia; in others (formerly B. tortuosa), it can be throughout the thallus.[2] Abundant, long, yellow pseudocyphellae indicate high vulpinic acid.[1] Its presence might be linked to a basidiomycete symbiont.[1] Traditional soaking may reduce vulpinic acid as it's slightly water-soluble.[1]

4.1.2. Other Identified Compounds

Traces of barbatolic and norstictic acid have been reported.[14] Lichens produce many secondary metabolites (depsides, depsidones, etc.), often up to 20% of thallus dry mass.[15][16]

4.2. General Biological Activities of Lichen Compounds

Lichen secondary metabolites exhibit various activities:[13][15]

Many lichen biosynthetic gene clusters are "silent," suggesting a vast unexplored chemical space.[15]

4.3. Specific Pharmacological Insights related to Bryoria fremontii

Bryoria fremontii contains toxic vulpinic acid.[1] However, vulpinic acid isolated from Letharia vulpina shows anticancer activity against various cell lines.[13] This highlights that a toxic raw compound can have therapeutic potential when purified and dosed correctly. Specific pharmacological studies on B. fremontii extracts are limited beyond vulpinic acid's general toxicity.[14]

Table 2: Key Bioactive Compounds and their Reported Activities

Compound Name Source Lichen Species Reported Biological Activity Key Details/Mechanism Source ID(s)
Vulpinic Acid Bryoria fremontii Toxicity Toxic in raw form; presence linked to yellow pseudocyphellae; water-soluble. [1]
Vulpinic Acid Letharia vulpina Anticancer Inhibits cell growth in various cancer cell lines (HepG2, CaCo2, RD, Wehi, Hep2C). [13]
Barbatolic Acid Bryoria fremontii (traces) Potential for broader activities Specific research on B. fremontii is limited. [14]
Norstictic Acid Bryoria fremontii (traces) Potential for broader activities Specific research on B. fremontii is limited. [14]
Usnic Acid General Lichens Antimicrobial, Antioxidant, Anti-inflammatory, etc. Destroys cell membranes, inhibits bacterial RNA synthesis, etc. [13]
Atranorin General Lichens Antimicrobial, Antioxidant, Anticancer Inhibits cell wall synthesis, phenolic compound, induces apoptosis. [13]

5. Cultivation and Propagation

5.1. Natural Dispersal and Reproductive Strategies

Bryoria fremontii primarily reproduces by thallus fragmentation, as soredia and apothecia are uncommon.[1] Wind disperses fragments effectively over considerable distances.[9] However, absence in young trees is likely due to substrate limitations, not dispersal.[9]

5.2. Challenges and Progress in Artificial Cultivation

Cultivating lichens is difficult; inducing symbiosis in vitro is often unsuccessful.[1][15] Challenges include slow growth and replicating environmental stimuli for secondary metabolite synthesis.[15] "Hyperabundance" of B. fremontii for caribou forage is linked to old-growth forests (stands >120–150 years old), known as the "old-growth paradox."[9]

Transplant studies show some progress: annual relative growth rates of 6.2% to 11.6%.[21] Growth was greatest near streams and in understory-thinned plots with low vapor pressure deficits (VPDs).[21] Denser surrounding forest buffers microclimate, favoring growth.[21] Thinning from below leaving large, live trees in clumps may foster growth.[21]

6. Future Potential Areas of Research

7. Conclusions

Bryoria fremontii is a biologically complex lichen with significant ecological and ethnobotanical importance. Its classification, morphology, and ecological role as caribou forage and a bioindicator are noteworthy. Traditional Indigenous knowledge transformed it into food and medicine. Phytochemically, vulpinic acid is key, being toxic raw but potentially therapeutic. Cultivation is challenging due to its old-growth dependency. Future interdisciplinary research is vital for understanding, conserving, and sustainably managing this remarkable species.


References

  1. Bryoria fremontii - Wikipedia, accessed May 21, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bryoria_fremontii
  2. (PDF) Molecular data show that Bryoria fremontii and B. tortuosa ..., accessed May 21, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/231925814_Molecular_data_show_that_Bryoria_fremontii_and_B_tortuosa_Parmeliaceae_are_conspecific
  3. Multi-locus phylogeny of Bryoria reveals recent diversification and unexpected diversity in section Divaricatae | The Lichenologist | Cambridge Core, accessed May 21, 2025, https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/lichenologist/article/multilocus-phylogeny-of-bryoria-reveals-recent-diversification-and-unexpected-diversity-in-section-divaricatae/327AA29157253C05F0F5B3FA8BB213FE
  4. Wila (Lichen) | Encyclopedia MDPI, accessed May 21, 2025, https://encyclopedia.pub/entry/31612
  5. Bryoria fremontii - The Global Fungal Red List Initiative, accessed May 21, 2025, https://redlist.info/iucn/species_view/341501
  6. Bryoria fremontii | NatureServe Explorer, accessed May 21, 2025, https://explorer.natureserve.org/Taxon/ELEMENT_GLOBAL.2.1037341/Bryoria_fremontii
  7. Stand openness predicts hair lichen (Bryoria) abundance in the lower canopy, with implications for the conservation of Canada's critically imperiled Deep-Snow Mountain Caribou (Rangifer tarandus caribou) - ResearchGate, accessed May 21, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/361942651_Stand_openness_predicts_hair_lichen_Bryoria_abundance_in_the_lower_canopy_with_implications_for_the_conservation_of_Canada's_critically_imperiled_Deep-Snow_Mountain_Caribou_Rangifer_tarandus_caribou
  8. Broad-scale distribution of epiphytic hair lichens correlates more ..., accessed May 21, 2025, https://cdnsciencepub.com/doi/10.1139/cjfr-2016-0113
  9. On the Dispersal of Hair Lichens (Bryoria) in High-Elevation ..., accessed May 21, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/285726170_On_the_Dispersal_of_Hair_Lichens_Bryoria_in_High-Elevation_Oldgrowth_Conifer_Forests
  10. The ethnolichenology of wila (Bryoria fremontii): an important edible ..., accessed May 21, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/367272178_The_ethnolichenology_of_wila_Bryoria_fremontii_an_important_edible_lichen_of_Secwepemc_country_and_neighbouring_territories
  11. Lichen Use, Sorted by Taxon, accessed May 21, 2025, https://www.sharnoffphotos.com/lichen_info/usetaxon.html
  12. (PDF) Lichens Used in Traditional Medicine - ResearchGate, accessed May 21, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/283808263_Lichens_Used_in_Traditional_Medicine
  13. Biological Activities and Potential Applications of Lichens - Medwin Publishers, accessed May 21, 2025, https://medwinpublishers.com/OAJMB/biological-activities-and-potential-applications-of-lichens.pdf
  14. Bryoria fremontii (Tuck.) Brodo & D. Hawksw. - ITALIC 8.0, accessed May 21, 2025, https://italic.units.it/index.php?procedure=taxonpage&num=339
  15. Breaking into nature's secret medicine cabinet: lichens – a ..., accessed May 21, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11923402/
  16. Discovery and excavation of lichen bioactive natural products - PMC - PubMed Central, accessed May 21, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10149937/
  17. Lichens: A myriad hue of Bioresources with medicinal properties, accessed May 21, 2025, https://oaji.net/articles/2017/736-1505841228.pdf
  18. “Medicinal Lichens”, by Robert Rogers - Alberta Mycological Society, accessed May 21, 2025, https://www.albertamushrooms.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Medicinal_lichens.pdf
  19. Lichens: A myriad hue of Bioresources with medicinal properties, accessed May 21, 2025, https://ijlsci.in/in/index.php/home/article/view/1407
  20. Lichen Subscribe - Morel Dilemma, accessed May 21, 2025, https://moreldilemma.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/morel-dilemma-script-3-lichen-subscribe.pdf
  21. Author's personal copy - Teakettle Ecosystem Experiment -UC Davis, accessed May 21, 2025, https://teakettle.ucdavis.edu/Presentations%20and%20papers/Bryoria%20growth%20in%20response%20to%20thinning%20Rambo%20FEM.pdf

Image References

  1. Jason Hollinger, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  2. Millifolium, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  3. Millifolium, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Bryoria Sp. in B.C.

Bryoria americana - Elegant horsehair [E-flora]
Bryoria bicolor - Electrified horsetail [E-flora]
Bryoria carlottae - Languid horsehair [E-flora]
Bryoria cervinula - Spiny horsehair [E-flora]
Bryoria fremontii - Edible horsehair [E-flora]
Bryoria friabilis - Friable horsehair [E-flora]
Bryoria fuscescens - Pale-footed horsehair [E-flora]
Bryoria glabra - Wire horsehair [E-flora]
Bryoria kockiana - boreal horsehair [E-flora]
Bryoria nitidula - Tundra horsehair [E-flora]
Bryoria pikei - Streaked horsehair [E-flora]
Bryoria pseudofuscescens - Mountain horsehair [E-flora]
Bryoria simplicior - Spangled horsehair [E-flora]
Bryoria tenuis - Pied horsehair [E-flora]
Bryoria tortuosa - Inedible horsehair [E-flora]